Skip to content

Differences Between Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards

Exploring the Differences Between Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards

Rewarding employees for their achievements and contributions is an integral part of any successful organization. However, not all rewards are created equal, and understanding the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards can greatly impact motivation and long-term performance. In this article, we will explore the psychology behind rewards, compare intrinsic and extrinsic rewards, discuss their role in different settings, and provide insights on how to choose the right reward system. Additionally, we will highlight the potential pitfalls of reward systems and emphasize the power of balanced rewards.

Understanding the Concept of Rewards

Before delving into the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards, it’s essential to grasp the concept of rewards themselves. Rewards are positive stimuli or incentives given to individuals in response to specific behaviors or accomplishments. They are designed to reinforce desired behaviors and motivate individuals to repeat those behaviors in the future. Rewards can take various forms, including tangible items, monetary compensation, recognition, praise, or even personal satisfaction and enjoyment. By understanding what rewards are and how they work, we can better appreciate the distinctions between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards.

When it comes to rewards, it’s important to recognize that they play a significant role in shaping human behavior. From a psychological perspective, rewards activate the brain’s pleasure centers, releasing neurotransmitters like dopamine, which create feelings of happiness and satisfaction. This biological response reinforces the connection between the behavior and the reward, making it more likely for individuals to engage in the desired behavior again.

Furthermore, rewards can have different effects depending on the context in which they are given. For example, in a work setting, rewards can serve as a form of feedback, indicating to employees that their efforts and contributions are valued. This recognition can boost morale and create a positive work environment conducive to productivity and job satisfaction.

Defining Intrinsic Rewards

Intrinsic rewards are those that come from within an individual. They are inherently satisfying and fulfilling, driven by internal motivation and personal values. Examples of intrinsic rewards include a sense of accomplishment, personal growth, autonomy, learning, and the enjoyment of the task itself. These rewards are often experienced when individuals engage in activities that align with their passions and interests.

One of the key characteristics of intrinsic rewards is their long-term impact on motivation and satisfaction. When individuals are intrinsically motivated, they are more likely to persist in their efforts, even when faced with challenges or setbacks. This internal drive fuels their desire to master skills, achieve personal goals, and experience a sense of fulfillment.

Moreover, intrinsic rewards can foster a sense of autonomy and creativity. When individuals find joy and satisfaction in their work, they are more likely to take ownership of their tasks and seek innovative solutions. This intrinsic motivation can lead to higher levels of engagement and productivity, as individuals are driven by their own internal desires rather than external pressures.

Defining Extrinsic Rewards

In contrast, extrinsic rewards are external incentives provided by others, such as employers or supervisors. They are typically tangible or monetary rewards, such as bonuses, promotions, gifts, or public recognition. Extrinsic rewards are aimed at motivating individuals through external stimuli and are often tied to specific outcomes or performance targets.

While extrinsic rewards can be effective in the short term, they may not lead to long-lasting motivation or job satisfaction. Research suggests that when individuals are primarily motivated by external rewards, their intrinsic motivation may diminish over time. This phenomenon, known as the “overjustification effect,” occurs when individuals start to view the task or behavior as a means to an end rather than an intrinsically rewarding activity.

Additionally, extrinsic rewards can create a competitive environment where individuals focus solely on achieving the reward rather than enjoying the process or developing a genuine interest in the task. This narrow focus on external outcomes may hinder creativity and intrinsic motivation, as individuals become more concerned with meeting external expectations rather than pursuing personal growth and fulfillment.

It’s important to note that while intrinsic and extrinsic rewards are often discussed as separate entities, they can coexist and complement each other. In some cases, extrinsic rewards can serve as a catalyst for individuals to discover intrinsic motivation and develop a genuine passion for their work. Likewise, intrinsic rewards can enhance the value and meaning individuals derive from external recognition or tangible rewards.

In conclusion, understanding the concept of rewards is crucial in comprehending the distinctions between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. By recognizing the different types of rewards and their impact on motivation and satisfaction, individuals and organizations can design reward systems that effectively promote desired behaviors, foster engagement, and cultivate a positive and fulfilling work environment.

The Psychology Behind Rewards

Understanding the psychological mechanisms underlying rewards can shed light on how intrinsic and extrinsic rewards influence behavior.

Rewards play a crucial role in shaping human behavior. They have the power to motivate individuals, drive performance, and shape decision-making processes. By delving into the psychology behind rewards, we can gain valuable insights into how they impact our thoughts, emotions, and actions.

When it comes to understanding rewards, it is essential to distinguish between two main types: intrinsic and extrinsic rewards.

How Intrinsic Rewards Influence Behavior

Intrinsic rewards tap into an individual’s natural desire for autonomy, mastery, and purpose. These rewards are deeply personal and are derived from within oneself. When people engage in activities they find intrinsically rewarding, they experience a deep sense of fulfillment and enjoyment.

Imagine a painter who loses track of time while creating a masterpiece, or a musician who feels a rush of joy when playing an instrument. These individuals are driven by their internal motivation, finding immense satisfaction in the process of their work. Intrinsic rewards can enhance creativity, stimulate problem-solving skills, and foster intrinsic motivation.

Moreover, intrinsic rewards often lead to a state of “flow,” where individuals are fully immersed in their tasks, experiencing a sense of timelessness and complete engagement. In this state, individuals are more likely to produce high-quality work and achieve a sense of self-actualization.

When employees are motivated by intrinsic rewards, their performance is often driven by a genuine passion for their work. They are more likely to go above and beyond, seeking personal growth and development. Intrinsic rewards create a positive work environment where individuals feel valued and fulfilled.

How Extrinsic Rewards Influence Behavior

Extrinsic rewards, on the other hand, are external incentives provided to individuals in response to their behavior or performance. These rewards can be powerful motivators, especially in situations where specific outcomes or performance targets need to be achieved.

Extrinsic rewards can take various forms, such as monetary bonuses, promotions, or public recognition. They provide clear goals and incentives for employees to strive for, leading to increased productivity and performance. For example, a salesperson may be motivated to achieve higher sales targets to earn a commission or a student may be driven to study harder to receive a scholarship.

However, it is crucial to note that overreliance on extrinsic rewards may undermine intrinsic motivation. When individuals become solely focused on obtaining the external reward, they may lose sight of the intrinsic value and enjoyment in their work.

Research suggests that when individuals are rewarded for completing a task, they may perceive the reward as the primary reason for engaging in the activity. Consequently, their intrinsic motivation may diminish, leading to a decline in creativity and overall satisfaction.

Furthermore, extrinsic rewards may create a dependency on external validation, making individuals less likely to take risks or explore new ideas. The fear of losing the reward can stifle innovation and limit long-term growth.

Therefore, finding the right balance between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards is crucial for organizations to foster a motivated and engaged workforce. By understanding the psychology behind rewards, employers can design reward systems that encourage both intrinsic motivation and achievement of organizational goals.

Comparing Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards

Now that we understand the psychological aspects of rewards, let’s delve deeper into the fascinating world of intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. By examining their impact on motivation and long-term performance, we can gain valuable insights into how to effectively motivate individuals in various contexts.

Key Differences in Motivation

Intrinsic rewards are driven by internal motivation, which stems from personal values, interests, and the inherent satisfaction gained from the task itself. When individuals are intrinsically motivated, they find joy and fulfillment in the process of completing a task, rather than relying on external factors for motivation. This type of motivation is deeply rooted in their own desires and aspirations.

On the other hand, extrinsic rewards are associated with external motivation, which is contingent on receiving external incentives or recognition. These rewards can take the form of tangible benefits such as money, promotions, or material possessions. Extrinsic motivation relies on the anticipation of rewards or the fear of punishment to drive individuals to perform certain tasks.

While both types of motivation can be effective, intrinsic motivation is generally regarded as more sustainable and conducive to long-term performance. When individuals are intrinsically motivated, they are more likely to engage in continuous learning, seek out challenges, and invest effort to achieve mastery. The joy and satisfaction derived from the task itself become the driving force behind their actions, leading to a deeper level of engagement and commitment.

Impact on Long-Term Performance

Intrinsic rewards have been found to contribute positively to long-term performance. When individuals are intrinsically motivated, they are more likely to persist in the face of challenges and setbacks. The inherent satisfaction they derive from the task fuels their perseverance and resilience, enabling them to overcome obstacles and achieve their goals.

Furthermore, intrinsic motivation fosters a growth mindset, where individuals view failures as opportunities for learning and improvement. They are more inclined to take risks, explore new ideas, and push the boundaries of their capabilities. This continuous learning and growth mindset contribute to long-term performance by enabling individuals to adapt to changing circumstances and seize new opportunities.

In contrast, a heavy reliance on extrinsic rewards can lead to a decrease in intrinsic motivation and a potential decline in long-term performance once the external incentives are removed. When individuals become solely focused on the rewards, they may lose sight of the intrinsic value of the task itself. As a result, their motivation becomes contingent on the presence of external rewards, and their performance may suffer once those rewards are no longer available.

Moreover, extrinsic rewards can inadvertently undermine individuals’ autonomy and intrinsic motivation. The external control and pressure associated with extrinsic rewards may diminish individuals’ sense of ownership and personal agency, leading to a decrease in their intrinsic motivation and overall performance.

In conclusion, while both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards have their place in motivating individuals, intrinsic rewards have been shown to have a more profound and lasting impact on long-term performance. By nurturing individuals’ internal motivation and fostering a sense of purpose and fulfillment, organizations and leaders can unlock the full potential of their teams and create a culture of sustained excellence.

The Role of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards in Different Settings

While intrinsic and extrinsic rewards have their unique characteristics, they also play specific roles in different settings, such as the workplace, education, and personal development.

Rewards in the Workplace

In the workplace, a combination of intrinsic and extrinsic rewards can be highly effective. Intrinsic rewards, such as opportunities for personal growth, autonomy in decision-making, and a supportive work environment, can foster employee satisfaction and commitment. Employees who are given the chance to develop new skills or take on challenging projects that align with their interests are more likely to feel a sense of fulfillment and purpose in their work. This, in turn, can lead to increased productivity and a higher level of job satisfaction.

On the other hand, well-designed extrinsic rewards, such as performance-based bonuses or recognition programs, can provide additional motivation and reinforce desired behaviors. Monetary rewards, for example, can serve as a tangible acknowledgment of an employee’s hard work and achievements. Recognition programs, whether in the form of awards or public acknowledgment, can also boost employee morale and create a positive work environment.

Rewards in Education

In the field of education, both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards are crucial for students’ motivation and engagement. Intrinsic rewards, such as a love for learning, intellectual curiosity, and the sense of accomplishment that comes from mastering challenging concepts, can enhance students’ intrinsic motivation. When students are genuinely interested in a subject and find it personally meaningful, they are more likely to be engaged and motivated to learn.

Extrinsic rewards, such as praise, grades, or certificates, can complement intrinsic motivation and provide tangible recognition for achieving academic milestones. Grades, for instance, serve as a measure of students’ academic performance and can provide feedback on their progress. Praise and certificates, on the other hand, can serve as external validation and acknowledgment of students’ hard work and achievements, boosting their self-esteem and confidence.

Rewards in Personal Development

When it comes to personal development, intrinsic rewards take center stage. Engaging in activities that align with personal passions, values, and interests can provide individuals with a sense of fulfillment, satisfaction, and personal growth. Pursuing hobbies, for example, allows individuals to explore their interests and develop new skills. Whether it’s painting, playing a musical instrument, or practicing a sport, engaging in intrinsically motivating activities can bring joy and a sense of accomplishment.

Volunteering is another example of a personally rewarding activity. By giving back to the community and helping others, individuals often experience a sense of purpose and fulfillment. The intrinsic reward of making a positive impact on the lives of others can be incredibly gratifying and can contribute to personal growth and development.

While extrinsic rewards may still play a role in personal development, intrinsically motivating activities tend to be more sustainable and impactful in this context. The satisfaction that comes from personal growth and self-improvement is often more lasting and fulfilling than external recognition or rewards.

Choosing the Right Reward System

Choosing the right reward system entails careful consideration of several factors to balance intrinsic and extrinsic rewards effectively. It’s essential to align rewards with individual and organizational goals, promote a sense of fairness and transparency, and acknowledge the unique preferences and motivations of employees. Additionally, leveraging employee communication and recognition platforms can greatly facilitate the implementation of an effective reward system. These platforms enable timely and meaningful recognition, peer-to-peer appreciation, and constant feedback, thus enhancing employee engagement and motivation.

Factors to Consider

When designing a reward system, consider factors such as the nature of the work, individual preferences, job design, organizational culture, and fairness. Developing clear criteria for rewards and ensuring that they are perceived as equitable and transparent can foster a positive work environment and motivate employees to perform at their best.

Balancing Intrinsic and Extrinsic Rewards

The key to a successful reward system lies in striking the right balance between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. While extrinsic rewards can serve as initial motivators, fostering intrinsic motivation through meaningful work, personal growth opportunities, and a supportive culture is essential for long-term engagement and performance. By combining both types of rewards strategically, organizations can create a holistic and sustainable reward system.

Potential Pitfalls of Reward Systems

While reward systems can be highly beneficial, there are potential pitfalls that organizations need to be aware of.

Over-Reliance on Extrinsic Rewards

Relying too heavily on extrinsic rewards may lead to a decline in intrinsic motivation. Employees may begin to focus solely on obtaining the external incentives, neglecting the intrinsic value and enjoyment they once found in their work. This can result in decreased creativity, reduced job satisfaction, and diminished long-term performance.

Ignoring the Power of Intrinsic Rewards

On the flip side, organizations that solely focus on extrinsic rewards may overlook the power of intrinsic rewards. Failing to create an environment that fosters personal growth, provides meaning, and cultivates a sense of purpose in work can hinder employee satisfaction, engagement, and retention. Organizations should recognize and appreciate the intrinsic rewards that come from the work itself.

Conclusion: The Power of Balanced Rewards

Successfully motivating employees and fostering long-term performance requires understanding the differences between intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. By leveraging their unique characteristics and balancing their use, organizations can create a reward system that taps into both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Through a careful and thoughtful approach to reward design, coupled with effective employee communication and recognition platforms, organizations can enhance employee engagement, satisfaction, and overall success.

Get Insights

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get more tips on effective employee engagement and communications!

Join Our Community

Join Turn On Engagement (TOE) to interact with other employee engagement and people experience professionals. Share and get new ideas!

Other posts you might enjoy

Back To Top